Saturday, October 6, 2012

Which is better Twilight or Harry Potter?


Question


Which is better Twilight or Harry Potter?
I have read both of these great book series but i like the Harry Potter books better. What do you guys think and why?


Answer


Ive read both books. My vote isbrbrbrHARRY POTTER.brbrbrCome on, guys, lets face it. HP is a fantasy kids story BUT even our old folks read it! It has something that Twilight doesnt have... depth. Im also a Twilight fan, but being a fan, i mean a HUGE fan, doesnt mean you no longer see the flaws of the things you idolize. HP has its own flaws too, but theyre quite forgivable...and excusable. Twilight has a number of questions left hanging after Breaking Dawn. Its just plain teen romance for me, with a touch of fantasy. I almost gave up reading when I was in New Moon. A thing that Ive NEVER felt while reading HP. To tell you, I hated HP so much before because Im not really into kids stuff like magic and spells, etc. But, it got me hooked up until the end. You have something to look forward to with every book. SM could stop writing at book three and it would still make sense, I mean youd still see the picture, a happy ending minus the wedding, of course. But, if JKR stopped at book three or four, youll be left wondering what happened with the other characters, theres an unfinished battle. Its not just a childish war. Its actually personal, there are a lot of questions regarding morality and responsibility that are answered in the books. And please, no one has the right to critique both books sans reading them. Thats how you COMPARE things. You look at both sides, or else your judgment would be biased. brbrHope this helps.



No comments:

Post a Comment